Best New Oreos of 2025, According to Pro Taste Testers

Every year, Oreo gives us something incredible and then takes it away. In 2025, two limited-time flavors were so good it felt borderline cruel when they vanished from shelves. These are the Oreos that defined the year—and, hey, maybe you can find them on eBay. (And they wonder why I have commitment issues?)

The following article contains affiliate links that may generate a small commission to us when you make a purchase through the link. Learn more about how we work with affiliates here.

Runner-Up

Apple Pie a la Mode Oreos

Walmart

These Apple Pie a la Mode Oreos almost came in first place. They, like our gold medal winner, also earned 10/10 Sporks in our initial view. Literally, our only complaint about them is that they’re a limited time flavor. (Why must the brightest stars burn the fastest?) These cookies taste like a heavenly slice of apple pie with a crumbly, buttery crust and a scoop of ice cream on top. We’d buy these just to flip the script and use them to top scoops of ice cream. I mean, they wouldn’t make it that far, because we’d eat them all first, but we love an Oreo that makes us fantasize. It’s actually insane that we liked another new Oreo just as much, if not better.

Credit: Liv Averett / Walmart

Rating:

10/10

Sporks

Best of the Best

Post Malone Oreos

Target

Post Malone. My guy. You’ve truly outdone yourself. We tried these and wondered if they were, perhaps, potentially, maybe, the best Oreo flavor of all time. Yes, really. Here’s the deal: It’s one chocolate cookie paired with one golden cookie, with a salted caramel and shortbread cream swirl. They’re stunning to look at and even more stunning to taste. The light saltiness in the caramel brings the whole thing together. Again, our only complaint: They’re limited edition—currently still on the shelves, though, so MAKE SURE TO BUY THEM. Do this for yourself. This year has been rough and you deserve a little joy.

Credit: Liv Averett / Target

Rating:

10/10

Sporks