If you don’t live in the mid-Atlantic, I genuinely pity you. No, not because New York, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey are the greatest states in the union—because you don’t have access to Wegmans. Ask anyone who lives in Wegmans’ sphere of influence and I guarantee they’ll tell you it’s their favorite supermarket by a mile. As soon as you walk in you’re greeted by soft warm lighting and the smell of fresh-cut flowers. Even your first time walking through the doors of a Wegmans will feel like you’re finally coming home after an arduous journey.
Videos by Sporked
Although Wegmans is one of our favorite grocery stores for fresh produce and offers a killer cheese department with an actual, literal cheesemonger on staff, its store-brand items in the middle aisles shouldn’t be overlooked. As a frequent flyer at my local Wegmans, I’ve compiled a list of my personal favorites and those that earn consistent high marks among customers. These are the goods to gloss over the name brands for.
Extra Creamy Oatmilk
I used to opt for Oatly or Chobani if I wanted a good all-purpose oat milk, but those days are long gone since I discovered Wegmans Extra-Creamy Oatmilk. It’s not quite as rich as the name brands, but it still adds a half-and-half-like level of creaminess to coffee while being refreshing enough to drink straight or use as a cereal milk—and at a fraction of the price of the big names, no less. I even add a little to curries for some added richness that doesn’t weigh down the recipe.
Amore Organic Tomato Basil Pasta Sauce
I’m all about homemade sauce, but I still believe everyone should keep a go-to jarred sauce on hand for impromptu pasta night, or to satisfy a lazy craving. This Wegmans product is that go-to, quintessential pasta sauce. The basil is prominent but still mellow enough that it can masquerade as a standard marinara. It’s delicious on its own and not too sweet and tart. However, squeeze a few roasted garlic cloves in and spruce it up with some black pepper and crushed red pepper and no one would believe it wasn’t homemade.
Ginger Sparkling Water
Wegmans seltzers can be hit or miss, but don’t sleep on the ginger flavor if you’re a fan of the spicy-sweet herb. Ginger sparkling waters are hard to come by in general and I’ve found that most lean a little too tart. Wegmans’ version tastes exactly like an unsweetened ginger ale, delivering a punch of flavor and none of the syrupy sweetness. I like to add a touch of agave to liven it up a bit.
Maple Creme Cookies
I’m a sucker for anything maple and any dessert with a cute aesthetic, so these cookies were a twofer. They look adorable on a party platter for an autumnal gathering or served alongside a steamy mug of cocoa or hot cider. There’s plenty of genuine maple flavor and they lean crunchy without being too hard on the teeth. They’re cookie-to-filling ratio is perfect—a rarity in the store-brand snack world.
Organic Whole Bean Donut Shop Blend
As a certified coffee snob, Wegmans’ Donut Shop Blend is the only store-bought coffee I’ll buy, period. It comes in a hefty two-pound bag to adequately satiate every caffeine addict, and it’s whole bean and organic—that’s not something you see too often with store-brand coffee. It’s fresh-tasting, light-bodied, and just a touch zesty and fruity—the perfect cup to wake up to.
Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!