Ever Dreamed Of A Pie-Sized Reese’s Cup? Your Prayers Have Been Answered

It’s a question we’ve all asked ourselves: What if a Reese’s peanut butter cup was big? Like, really big? And I’m not talking King Size Cups, or even its Jumbo Cups; I’m talking super big. “Size of a pie” big. Would it have the same flavor? How would Reese’s even pull off such a thing? And where would this massive Reese’s pie be sold? In a warehouse club, perchance? And maybe it would appear sometime before Christmas in 2026, right?

Videos by Sporked

Why, yes. Yes, it would. That’s my less-than-elegant way of saying that Reese’s has just made a pie version of its peanut butter cup, and it’s available now. Shall we discuss? 

Reese’s Pie

This week, food content creator @jerseyfoodnfinds found the new Reese’s Pie at BJ’s Wholesale, and in doing so, a quest that Reese’s started several years ago has come around once more. Those of you with good memory might recall that Reese’s actually debuted its first pie version of its peanut butter cup back in 2021, which, like this one, also dropped shortly before Thanksgiving. That pie sold out within hours, so it would have been no surprise if you missed it the first time around – and then Reese’s decided to put the whole thing to bed for half a decade. 

Now, though, the Reese’s Pie is back in stock, baby. This thing weighs in at over three pounds, and judging by the calories per serving printed on the box, it’s meant to serve 48 people. Talk about slivers. That makes sense, though, considering that in total, the Reese’s Pie comes in at 7,680 calories. And honestly, it really does just seem like a massive version of a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup: According to the DoorDash listing for this pie, it’s made up of milk chocolate and a peanut filling, just as the smaller ones are. A few people out there are gonna be very happy.

But How Much Does It Cost?

Well, it’s not cheap. The Reese’s Pie is currently priced at around $39.99 at BJ’s Wholesale. It’s unclear which other stores will be stocking it this year, and for how long it’ll be sticking around. I personally wouldn’t be surprised if this is a fairly limited release, and once this run of pies is gone, they’re gone. If you want a bit of wow factor at your Thanksgiving table, though, and for everyone to be plunged into a sugar crash afterward, track it down before it’s too late.