In the lead up to Thanksgiving, Crumbl is turning to pies and other classic desserts for their cookie flavor inspiration. But, of everything on the menu this week the thing that really caught our eye was the French Silk Pie. Of every kind of pie, we think that the French silk pie is dramatically underrated for what it is and deserves more time in the sun.
Videos by Sporked
The combination of a cookies and cream piecrust and rich, luscious chocolate mousse just sounded too perfect to pass up on. So, of course we knew we would have to run out to Crumbl and get one for us to try. And, who would we be as food writers if we didn’t share our findings with our dear readers? So let’s get into our official Sporked review.
Our Official Thoughts
The thing that was most frustrating about this dessert is that no matter the amount of attempts we give Crumbl to redeem its non-cookie menu items, they always fall short. Not only does it just not make sense to be replacing cookies at Crumbl Cookies with non-cookie items in the first place, but they are always a clear demonstration of something that either hasn’t had enough attention in the development phase or hasn’t been executed at the national level with the quality that it should’ve.
The truth of the matter is that people go to Crumbl for cookies. And if they are going to be putting a non-cookie item on the menu, they should be 100% worth the attention. This French Silk Pie was just another iteration of something that would have benefitted from being replaced by a cookie. No part of this really felt like a valid reason to replace a cookie. Was it terrible or gross? No. But is it just yet another Oreo-based dessert from Crumbl that’s just a glorified scoop of chocolate pudding in the end? Yes! There’s no balance or redeeming quality that would make this a worthwhile eat.
It honestly felt like eating a dirt cake, but even then it felt more bland and less fun. But, for the sake of fairness, I guess it is still worth mentioning that the texture of the mousse was nice. It wasn’t at all like what the texture of an actual French silk pie should be, but it was nice. I just don’t understand why they feel the need to make alternative desserts when the rest of the “pies” represented on the menu this week were pie-inspired cookies that at least made sense for the restaurant.
Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!