Papa John’s Will Shut Down 300 Locations: Here’s Why

Copy this link to share with your friends!

https://sporked.com/article/papa-johns-will-shut-down-300-locations-heres-why/

If you’re a dedicated Papa John’s pizza fan, the year ahead is looking a little bleak. That’s because Papa John’s hasn’t exactly been expanding. Rather, the pizza chain has been shrinking, both in how much pizza it’s sold and the number of restaurants or stores it operates.

Videos by Sporked

And according to the latest reports from Papa John’s, it just might get trickier to grab your go-to pie in the months ahead. Hundreds of locations are set to shutter throughout 2026 and 2027 — and we’ve learned why the closures are happening.

Papa John’s Is Aiming for Growth in 2027

Papa John’s CEO Todd Penegor is all about the future when it comes to the year ahead. Part of the reason 300 store locations are closing is, according to a statement reported in The Independent, because “We have aligned our company and franchisees behind a clear strategy for growth.”

That new strategy, which is an initiative called Unbox Better, was announced during the most recent Papa John’s earnings call. It will include new in-store training for staff, improved operational standards, and a refreshed menu. And it may even include the chain’s new ask to be honest about its pizza.

And if store locations are underperforming from the growth POV, they won’t be part of the brand’s plans going forward.

Papa John’s hasn’t seen its sales grow in a positive direction in over a year. On the other hand, competitors Domino’s (the most popular pizza chain) and Pizza Hut have both seen an increase in sales over the past summer.

Papa John’s Hasn’t Had an Easy Year (and Neither Has Pizza in General)

While Papa John’s is spinning all 300 of these store closures as a good thing for future growth and (hopefully) revenue, it’s not all rainbows and sunshine for this pizza brand. In fact, Papa John’s has had a pretty rough go of it this year. And when things take a turn for the worse, store closures are always in the cards.

According to the latest earnings call and the data revealed during it, Papa John’s has seen year-over-year sales drop by 8.5 percent from July to September 2026. And that’s not the first time the chain has seen its sales decline. Papa John’s closed out 2025 with a sales decline of 5 percent — and that’s when the plan to shutter 300 underperforming restaurants was originally revealed.

So, in addition to stores closing due to sinking sales and a reprioritization of growth, Papa John’s locations will also close if they are part of that underperforming group. Locations that don’t meet brand expectations, don’t have a path to sustainable financial improvement, are over 10 years old, and make an average unit volume of less than $600,000 will be on the chopping block.

Papa John’s locations have already begun closing under these new guidelines. The closures will continue into 2027, however. 200 stores were planned for closure in 2026; the remaining 100 will close by the end of next year.

And it’s not just Papa John’s that’s had a hard time lately. According to The Wall Street Journal, pizza in general has fallen out of favor with diners over the last 30 years. It’s now the sixth most popular cuisine based on sales — and even bigger names like Pizza Hut have plans to shutter hundreds of stores.

So, if your local Papa John’s is still around, you’re in luck. But it could still come up as one of the locations slated to close in the next year… or in the future if pizza in general can’t turn things around.

Copy this link to share with your friends!

https://sporked.com/article/papa-johns-will-shut-down-300-locations-heres-why/


About the Author

Heather Adams

Heather Adams has spent over a decade writing about food, health, and wellness for publications including Clean Eating, Vegetarian Times, Outside, and Healthversed, which means she's read an alarming amount about what people should eat. What people actually eat? That's way more fun. She's always down to debate the best fast-food fries, has a soft spot for Chick-fil-A, firmly believes a great cauliflower taco can change your day, and will never walk past a cute (perhaps even bear-shaped) novelty cup without considering whether it needs to come home with her. She's also proof that even someone who's burned Easy Mac in the microwave more than once can have strong opinions about food.

Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!

Your thoughts.