With Thanksgiving being just a week a week away now, it finally feels appropriate for the hazy whispers of the holiday festivities to come into focus. And, since we’re food writers, for us that of course means the flavors that come along with it. There is one company in particular that we always look forward to the return of their holiday menu each and every year: Chick-fil-A.
Videos by Sporked
And we won’t sugar coat it, this is greatly due to the perfection that they have achieved with their Peppermint Chip Milkshake. Each year when it comes back, we have somehow forgotten just how delicious it is, and this year they’re riding that wave of success and debuting three all-new peppermint drinks to coincide the return of the milkshake. But now, since this new menu has four peppermint drinks to choose from, the question remains of which one you should get. That’s exactly the question that we here at Sporked are here to answer for you. So without further ado, this is our official Chick-fil-A peppermint menu ranking.
- Peppermint Iced Coffee
-
This drink is far and by the only one that I would not order again. In this drink, it feels like the flavor of the coffee and peppermint are actually fighting with each other, and they’re almost bringing out the worst in each other’s flavors, too. Plus, the quality of the coffee overall tastes more bitter and acidic in this drink than in the cold brew, making it a distinctively lesser option in this collection.
- Peppermint Chip Frosted Coffee
-
Honestly, it was really refreshing to see that none of the coffee drinks in this collection were overpowered by the creamy peppermint flavors. Even in this frozen blended coffee, the first thing you taste is still the coffee itself, but in the form of a classic Peppermint Chip Milkshake from Chick-fil-A. There are even the same chocolate and peppermint candy bits incorporated throughout the blended drink, but in this case I don’t really think it serves the drink properly. Because the frozen coffees are a bit looser than a milkshake in consistency, it feels less harmonious with the drink overall. That said, I would still happily finish this drink and order it again if I was wanting the peppermint milkshake with an extra dose of caffeine.
- Peppermint Cream Cold Brew
-
It’s delightful to have a peppermint coffee that doesn’t have a mocha or chocolate element to it. You still get that peppermint flavor that you love, but you can actually taste the coffee still since the chocolate isn’t overwhelming it. And, since cold brew is naturally so strong, the creaminess and bright sweetness of the peppermint balances and mellows it out quite nicely. For this drink in particular, I would just say that it’s important to know that the peppermint flavor itself is very strong. You can still taste the coffee and they sing together in a delicious harmony. But, if you’re not the kind of person who doesn’t like an aggressive, bold peppermint flavor, then this isn’t gonna be the drink for you.
- Peppermint Chip Milkshake
-
For as open as we were to a new, coffee-infused creation to take the title of best holiday drink from Chick-fil-A this year, there is just something about the classic that can’t be topped. You’ll notice that the Peppermint Cream Cold Brew holds the same official Sporked rating, to which we must affirm to you that the Peppermint Chip Milkshake and Peppermint Cream Cold Brew are equal in caliber. Both are a truly perfect version of what they are. But they serve such different purposes, and we will almost certainly be more inclined to lean into the classic milkshake instead due to the nature of the restaurant overall. The shake is creamy, refreshing, sweet, and seasonal, and we simply can’t get enough. Plus, anything with whipped cream and a cherry on top will always have our hearts.
Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!