ALL the Pepperidge Farm Holiday Cookies Returning for 2025

There’s a Pepperidge Farm outlet store a short drive from my house. Do you know how dangerous that is? Most days, I can get a bag of Milano cookies there for less than two dollars. Did I say a bag? One time, I bought thirty bags and started handing out cookies like some sort of reverse Santa—and everyone loved them. The point here is that Pepperidge Farm’s cookies make everyone happy.

There are eight different Pepperidge Farm holiday cookies hitting shelves now. While none of them are new, there are so many P.F. cookies that you may not recognize all of them! If you’d like to be a 2025 cookie completionist, you’ll want to keep your eyes out for these at your favorite grocery store.

Amaretto Hot Chocolate Milano

My dog Skye is pretty dumb. She’s still young and Pomskies weren’t bred to have brain cells, so I can’t really hold it against her. That said, when I found out she had eaten an entire bag of these cookies including most of the bag off a desk, she truly entered a new echelon of empty-headed. (She was fine.) This particular offense was extra hurtful since Amaretto Hot Chocolate is not only the best Milano variant, but the best Pepperidge Farm cookie ever made.

Thin & Crispy Peppermint Cocoa Cookies

These Pepperidge Farm holiday cookies launched last year in what I swore was a direct attack on Tate’s Bake Shop. I’m not sure what this national obsession with thin, crispy cookies is; as a red bag Chips Ahoy fan, I’d like the pendulum to shift the other direction ASAP. But our own Jessica Block gave these an 8 out of 10 when she reviewed them last year, so these chocolate cookies with peppermint chips must stick the landing.

Mint Brussels

We all talk about the stranglehold pumpkin spice has on autumn, but no one mentions the ironclad grip of mint chocolate on the holiday season. Mint Brussels are a thin cookie atop a layer of dark chocolate with mint flavoring shoved in there somewhere to truly make this a special occasion. 

Holiday Nog Chessmen

How do we feel about eggnog as a flavor? I’m seeing more and more nog-flavored products come across my desk. This noggy variant of the year-round Butter Chessmen cookies is definitely one of the classier options. Dipping this shortbread cookie in some spirited eggnog would make for a very merry happy.

Raspberry Linzer

Pepperidge Farm is very good at classing up a simple thing. They’ve made their name in fancy versions of sandwich cookies like the Linzer cookie, which gets an exclusive raspberry filling this time of year. The snowflake imprint is a nice touch that all your party guests will definitely notice and compliment.

Sugar Zurich and Ginger Gingerman

These two cookies are on shelves year-round, but the red sprinkle variants are exclusive to these chilly months at the end of the calendar. It’s not a groundbreaking change, but being a cookie completionist means covering everything.

Peppermint Milano Slices

I said it last year and I’ll say it again: This is 2/3rds of a Milano cookie. They’ve replaced the top cookie with a smattering of peppermint shards and we’re supposed to be grateful? (Rise up, cookie proletariat; don’t let them short you 1/3rd of your little treats.) At least the chocolate used here is dark chocolate; Pepperidge Farm’s dark chocolate cookies are just miles ahead of every milk chocolate variant.