Since 1985, Pillsbury has been putting Toaster Strudels on shelves for our toasting pleasure. Here in 2024, we’re blessed with at least a dozen flavors available at the same time. So, against our better judgements, we’ve corralled every flavor we can find into one comprehensive ranking. From the classic Toaster Strudels to the savory Toaster Scrambles and even the innovative Toaster Donuts, we’ve squeezed more icing than you can shake a doughboy at.
We tasted every Toaster Strudel flavor that is currently on the market—including Toaster Scrambles!—in an attempt to find the most elite freezer section pastry. Breakfast lovers, this is a ranking for you!
The following article contains affiliate links that may generate a small commission to us when you make a purchase through the link. Learn more about how we work with affiliates here.
- Cinnamon Roll Toaster Strudel
-
There’s no point in buying this Toaster Strudel flavor. It doesn’t taste nearly as good as a cinnamon roll and it is way worse than all the other Toaster Strudel flavors. I know it sounds like it would be good, but leave this box on the shelf. — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Merc / Instacart
- Apple Toaster Strudel
-
Apple is a step up from Cinnamon Roll for sure, but it’s nothing to write home about. If you absolutely love apple pie and want it for breakfast, try these! If not, you can skip this Toaster Strudel flavor. — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Merc / Instacart
- Rainbow Sprinkle Toaster Donut
-
The entire Toaster Donut line features a “new donut texture” that blows away the standard Toaster Strudel pastry. That said, this specific variant loses points for breaking with standard Toaster Strudel procedure by offering a single packet of sprinkles for all six pastries. Great pastry, but no mom is ordering this a second time after witnessing the Who Got More Sprinkles debate. — Griffin Parker
Credit: Liv Averett / Instacart
- Cherry Toaster Strudel
-
As you’d expect, this is a very candy-like cherry filling. I’m usually very pro-cherry, but this gets close to that Medicinal Taste Wall that plagues a lot of cherry-flavored treats. There are better Toaster Strudel flavors, but this feels quintessentially Toaster Strudel—for better or for worse. — Griffin Parker
Credit: Liv Averett / Walmart
- Frosted Toaster Donut
-
The pastry texture is fantastic and the
finger glueicing is as good as it’s ever been, but it still feels weird that this Toaster Strudel isn’t filled with anything. If they would just fill this donut pastry with the Strawberry Strudel filling, this would easily be an 11/10. — Griffin ParkerCredit: Liv Averett / Instacart
- Boston Cream Toaster Donut
-
This is the only Toaster Donut with a filling, so by default, it’s my favorite of the subline. Chocolate icing is a pleasant upgrade from the classic flavor. Still, the Boston Cream-iness of it didn’t blow me away like I was hoping for. This met expectations. That is all. — Griffin Parker
Credit: Liv Averett / Instacart
- Strawberry Toaster Strudel
-
Strawberry is a classic Toaster Strudel flavor and a real crowd pleaser. It’s perfectly sweet and fruity. Both kids and adults can get behind this. It’s a tad basic, but what’s so wrong with that? — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Liv Averett / Target
- Cream Cheese & Strawberry Toaster Strudel
-
You should skip the regular strawberry and get the cream cheese and strawberry Toaster Strudel flavor. The addition of the cream cheese makes it feel like a fancy danish from a bakery. The creamy cream cheese and the fruity strawberry go great with the flaky pastry and gooey icing. — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Merc / Instacart
- Blueberry Toaster Strudel
-
After so many aggressively fake fruit flavors, this Toaster Strudel flavor was a real surprise. Going from the Cherry Toaster Strudel to this was basically 0 to 100 in terms of “actually tasting like the intended fruit.” I’ve had actual blueberry pastries that weren’t this good. What timeline are we living in? — Griffin Parker
Credit: Merc / Toaster Strudel
- Sausage Toaster Scrambles
-
The savory breakfast Toaster Strudel flavors (aka Toaster Scrambles) are a revelation. They are so incredibly delicious. If you told me these were pastries from an expensive bakery that you had to wait in line for a long time to buy, I’d believe you! The sausage is savory, the cheese is rich, the eggs are fluffy, and the pastry is melty. I have literally no notes. — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Merc / Target
- Bacon Toaster Scrambles
-
The bacon Toaster Strudel is my personal favorite Toaster Strudel flavor. The smoky bacon and rich, cheesy eggs make the ideal filling. As always, the pastry is light and airy. This is the kind of breakfast you dream about waking up to in the morning. — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Merc / Instacart
- Raspberry Toaster Strudel
-
Raspberry is, hands down, the best Toaster Strudel flavor if you have a sweet tooth. The filling has a slight tartness that the other fruit flavors lack, which adds so much to the pastry. It’s a little more complex. This is not only the best Toaster Strudel flavor, it’s one of the best pastries you can buy at the grocery store. I mean that! — Jordany Myrick
Credit: Merc / Instacart
Cinnamon Roll
Apple
Rainbow Sprinkle
Cherry
Frosted Donut
Boston Cream
Strawberry
Cream Cheese & Strawberry
Blueberry
Sausage
Bacon
Raspberry
