The holidays are here which means that all our favorite quintessentially winter flavors are here. Dunkin’s fully embracing that mood by unveiling a menu that’s focused all around one of the most iconic holiday flavors. What, what’s this? They’ve released a cookie butter menu? I mean I love cookie butter, but I wouldn’t necessarily call it a winter flavor.
Videos by Sporked
Don’t get me wrong, I’ll enjoy it in the winter but I’ll also dig into cookie butter during the spring, summer, and fall, too. Whatever. I guess they had to release it sometime. Well, let’s give it a try. Here are our thoughts on all the “festive” drinks on Dunkin’s new cookie butter menu.
Cookie Butter Cloud Latte
Pros: Sadly, the most cookie butter flavor I found in all of Dunkin’s cookie butter menu was from the crumbles of cookie on top of their Cloud Latte―which is a shame because I signed up for this whole taste test because I love cookie butter. We’re not off to a great start.
Cons: Even the cookie butter cold foam that we’ll be talking about a lot in this article was lacking in true, bright cookie butter flavor. I’m honestly impressed they were able to dull such an intense flavor. The base latte of this drink wasn’t doing things any favors. The espresso was just incredibly bitter. Thank goodness the rest of the drink was unbelievably sweet so I could try (and still somewhat fail) to mask the espresso by mixing things up.
Cookie Butter Cloud Dunkalatte
Pros: Am I going crazy? What is the actual difference between the “Dunkalatte” and the Cloud Latte? Besides the cookie crumbles on top of the Cloud Latte which were the best part of the whole drink, these are seemingly the same drink. Except for the sharp espresso taste which is missing from this version. So whatever the heck the difference is between a Dunkalatte and a Cloud Latte, the Dunkalatte gets a narrow victory.
Cons: We’re sorely missing the cookie crumbles in the Dunkalatte. Those were the best part of the whole drink! Again, the cookie butter is really muted here but it still somehow manages to be just a few notches too sweet for my liking.
Cookie Butter Hot Chocolate
Pros: If you’re looking for cookie butter in your actual drink, then this is surprisingly your best bet out of the whole lineup―which goes against my usual “I don’t like to mix delicate flavors with chocolate” mindset. Somehow Dunkin’ is able to help the cookie butter stay separate but also incorporate into the hot chocolate. The actual hot chocolate itself was deliciously smooth which was only added onto by the silky cookie butter. If I had to get one of these again in their base form, I would get this one every single time.
Cons: I’ll call it a con that a donut and coffee shop’s best item on their limited menu was the hot chocolate. What are we doing, Dunkin’?
Cookie Butter Matcha
Pros: My first few sips were pretty good! And then I got to the matcha underneath the cookie butter cold foam. Surprisingly out of the three drinks that use cookie butter cold foam, this is the one that you can taste the cookie butter the most. I think it’s mostly just due to there being more of a separation between the cold foam and the matcha latte as you start the drink.
Cons: The sharp difference between the cookie butter cold foam and matcha latte underneath is simply not for me. While I don’t have the most experience with matcha, I’m going to go ahead and assume that Dunkin’s is also not the best example of the drink anyway. I just can’t fathom a world where someone cares so much about matcha, but chooses to get it at Dunkin’ in the first place.
Cookie Butter Oat Chai Latte
Pros: Dunkin’s chai latte has a delicious flavor. The cinnamon and clove are perfect for the cooling temps. Even if I did get this one iced. Whoops! I have a preference, what can I say? The flavor kept me coming back for more and more sips, even if I came to regret it.
Cons: Holy sweetness. Things being too sweet were a general problem with this limited-time menu but this was the worst offender. I can’t even tell if the sweetness is solely from the cookie butter or not because it wasn’t as bad as this in the previous drinks. Though those mostly used the cookie butter cold foam and this does not.
I really did favor this one for the chai latte of it all but my stomach actually couldn’t handle too many sips. If they dialed back the sweetener (which you can do when you order but it’s a shame they don’t do it by default) then I could see myself getting this one again.
Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!