One Of Sam’s Club’s Best Pies Is Back In Stock

The bakery at Sam’s Club is really churning out the good stuff right now. In the last couple of weeks, its bakery has been the site of constant activity, as the store straddles the end of summer and the start of fall. That means we’ve been seeing cookie trays, mini pie and cheesecake combos, pumpkin spice cake balls, and pumpkin spice cakes (in non-ball form) – and as we push towards September, it’s all starting to feel very cozy. 

Videos by Sporked

The return of one pie in particular has definitely made us feel that way. One of Sam’s Club’s fan-favorite pies is now back in stock for fall, and it’s got me wishing we had the chain over here in the UK. Ah, well. In another life, maybe. Here’s what you should know. 

Sam’s Club Member’s Mark Cherry Lattice Pie

As confirmed by @samsclubfavorites on TikTok, Sam’s Club Member’s Mark Cherry Lattice Pie is now available in its stores once more. Each 40-oz pie is priced at around $10, and it can serve nine people (although that’s entirely dependent on the size of your slices – and if you find that it serves eight, or six, or four, then we won’t be judging you for that). Made with whole cherries, the filling pokes through the golden lattice crust in a very storybook-esque way: We can see this one sitting on the windowsill, releasing trails of aroma, perhaps for an errant wolf to be lured to and eat. 

Sam’s Club’s Cherry Lattice Pie was first released in Spring 2025, and since then, it’s racked up a lot of positive reviews. And we mean a lot. On the Sam’s Club website, it currently boasts a 4.5-star rating and well over 1,600 reviews, the vast majority of them giving it a five out of five. “Loved Sam’s cherry pie. It had the right amount of sweetness that combined well with the tartness of the cherries. If you like your cherry pie with a bit of tartness, this pie is for you,” said one particularly happy customer. 

Available Now!

Sam’s Club’s Cherry Lattice Pie is a seasonal item, and, likely, it won’t be around for more than a few months – so grab it before it’s gone. We recommend serving it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream…and not to encourage cheating on Sam’s Club with a fellow big-box store, but it might be worth scooting over to Costco to get theirs, given how good it is.