Each year, there will always be the ever-evolving debate of what should and shouldn’t be included on the Thanksgiving table. Not only are these preferences determined by which region, culture, and demographic you come from within the United States, but Thanksgiving dinner preferences are also so intrinsically linked to family traditions and personal preferences. All of this to say, it’s difficult to determine a finite list of what the mandatory elements of a Thanksgiving feast are.
Videos by Sporked
Going off of the fact that these things will always be determined by preferences in the end, we do still think that there are certain qualities and characteristics of dishes that should have hard-and-fast standards around them. Stuffing, in particular, is one of those dishes that we could go on and on about. We have a lot to say about stuffing and how it should be made and enjoyed, so let’s get into it, shall we?
The Basics
Before we get into any hot takes, it is fundamentally essential to establish the fact that we believe stuffing to be a required dish on the Thanksgiving table. Whether it’s the star of the show or a side character can be totally up to you and your loved ones, but the dish in and of itself encapsulates the flavors of the holiday into one concise bite. Hours before Thanksgiving dinner is ready to be served, the aroma of a complete feast will permeate your home simply due to the ingredients and preparation processes of making stuffing. To us, it’s a non-negotiable. And, even if there are perhaps more interesting or trendy options available on the table, stuffing is just too classic to replace or go without.
The Cardinal Sin Is Stuffing Your Bird
Another reason stuffing is so beloved by us is due to how endlessly customizable it is. And, one of the key ways people consider it to be customizable is through the choice of baking it as a casserole versus actually stuffing it into your turkey and baking it as one. But, we don’t think this should even be a debate at this point for a pretty practical, essential reason.
When stuffing is stuffed into a turkey, or any piece of poultry for that matter, it does a couple of things. Filling the cavity does allow for better heat circulation of the bird. But, the stuffing inside of the turkey will inevitably take longer to cook than the meat itself — the white meat in particular. And, since the stuffing is inside a piece of poultry the drippings of the meat will be all of the filling. So, if it hasn’t reached the same food safe temperature as the rest of the bird, it can risk contaminating your loved ones with salmonella.
But, if you go out of your way to avoid this by cooking the whole bird until the stuffing has reached the correct internal temperature, then your meat will be overcooked. To us, it just seems like such a no-brainer to entirely avoid this issue by simply baking the two separately. Just fill your turkey with some onions and aromatics and use the drippings to make your gravy that you’ll drown your stuffing in anyways. It’s a simple solution to an actual food safety issue that will actually make it so that each component — the turkey and the stuffing — are both of the highest quality.
Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!