Avast, me gluten free hearties! Chips Ahoy! finally released a gluten free version of its iconic chocolate chip cookies, and as is our bounden duty as professional testers of all things taste, we must let you all know if this GF version of the classic cookie holds up, or if it—much like most book-to-movie adaptations, pancakes that were accidentally flipped onto the floor, and me tripping over my own feet—falls flat.

Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!