Jeni’s Holiday Collection Will Leave You Feeling Merry

Christmas is a time for ice cream. Hey, any day of the year is a time for ice cream. But when the Yuletide arrives? It’s a ready-made excuse. Naturally, ice cream brands need little excuse to respond, too, and we’ve already started seeing them bring out their holiday offers. A couple of weeks back, Clementine’s Ice Cream dropped its Holiday Cookie Exchange Collection, and now we’re getting a suite of festive flavors from Jeni’s. 

Videos by Sporked

And there are some returning favorites here that customers are very pleased about. Let’s check out what Jeni’s is rolling out for Christmas 2026. 

Jeni’s Holiday Collection

Jeni’s Ice Cream’s Holiday Collection has just been revealed by @candyhunting over on Instagram, and the ice cream brand is offering six flavors in it. The majority of the flavors are ones we’ve seen before, but there’s one in there that’s a newbie – and which, as a Brit, I’m very happy to see getting a frozen version. 

Jeni’s Holiday Collection includes:

• Cranberry Panettone with Chocolate Sprinkles: A brioche-scented base is mixed with cranberry-orange jam and chocolate sprinkles. 
• Pistachio Macaron: Pistachio cream (made with pistachio butter), a suggestion of honey, and a touch of almond extract. 
• White Chocolate Peppermint: They don’t get more festive than this! White chocolate cream mixed with real peppermint, doused in white chocolate sprinkles and hit with a pop of sea salt. 
• Boozy Eggnog: An egg custard, mixed with nutmeg and a touch of Uncle Nearest Whiskey. 
• Black Tie Tiramisu: A dual swirl of mocha and mascarpone ice creams, mixed with ladyfinger cookies and a chocolate drizzle. 
• Sticky Toffee Pudding: And finally, the new flavor: vanilla and date custard, combined with brown sugar cake and a buttery toffee sauce.

Get Ready!

All of these flavors have their own fans, and on @candyhunting’s post, Jeni’s aficionados were quick to highlight which ones they were excited about. Boozy Eggnog received a particularly strong crowd showing up for it, with one person saying that it’s “quite literally the best ice cream flavor to ever exist.” We gave it a 10/10 when we tried it a few years back, too, so we concur. The Sticky Toffee Pudding flavor, though, is also generating excitement – and if this one’s anything like the desserts I used to get at the end of my school dinners as a kid, Jeni’s is on to a winner. Squidgy, fudgy, slightly malty, and with more butter and sugar than you can shake a stick at – it’s a prizewinner of a pudding. This flavor also recently showed up at Walmart; is there a sticky toffee trend on its way?

That remains to be seen, but if you want to sample this collection, it’ll be available from October 20 online and in Jeni’s scoop shops. Jeni’s Rewards members, meanwhile, can grab it now. The flavors will also be available at certain retailers.