Reese’s Pieces With Chocolate Cookie May Be Back, But They Aren’t 100% New

If the rumors are true, then Reese’s Pieces fans are in for a big surprise! An Instagram post is sparking excitement over Reese’s Pieces Chocolate Cookie. For many people in Canada, the candy is already a familiar sight on store shelves. For Americans, however, it looks like a long-awaited new flavor that could finally be making its way south of the border. At least, that’s what it looks like at first glance.

Videos by Sporked

As excitement builds online, and even Reese’s itself joins in on the teasing, the news of this chocolatey twist on Reese’s Pieces turns out to be a little more complicated than social media would have everyone believe.

The Big Surprise

The latest buzz started after popular food content creator Snackolator shared an image of Reese’s Pieces Chocolate Cookie, suggesting the candy would soon be available in the United States. The excitement grew even more when the official Reese’s Instagram account commented on the post with a teasing “surprise 😏,” leading many fans to assume a nationwide launch could be on the horizon.

The candy itself puts a twist on the classic Reese’s Pieces formula. Traditional Reese’s Pieces feature a peanut butter center inside a crunchy candy shell. This version adds a chocolate cookie center into the mix, creating a crunchier texture and a cookies-and-chocolate flavor profile alongside the familiar peanut butter taste. The product has existed in Canada for several years, where it developed a somewhat small―but passionate―following among candy lovers.

But It’s Not A New Cookie

At first glance, the social media claims make it sound like American candy lovers are about to experience something entirely new. That may end up being true for many consumers, but not because the candy has never crossed the border before.

In September 2025, we reviewed Reese’s Pieces Chocolate Cookie after finding them at a Hershey’s Chocolate World location in New York City. At the time, the candy was also available through Hershey’s online store. This is particularly important because saying the candy is “coming soon” to the U.S. for the first time suggests Americans have never been able to buy it. In reality, Americans could already get their hands on it if they visited a Chocolate World location or ordered directly from Hershey. The real question is whether Reese’s is preparing something bigger this time around.

What the Latest Teaser Might Actually Mean

The recent wave of excitement around Reese’s Pieces Chocolate Cookie feels less like an introduction and more like a reintroduction. The product already exists. American consumers have already tasted it. In fact, reviews have already been written. The only thing missing is a proper nationwide launch.

For now, Reese’s hasn’t confirmed exactly when the Pieces Chocolate Cookie is coming to the US. But whether it comes in July or the coming months, just know that the rest of the country is finally getting access to a secret that snack hunters have known about for over a year now.