Eating all 52 flavors of Ben & Jerry’s pints seems like a dream. But then the spoonfuls start coming. And coming. And they don’t stop. In celebration of their 1,700 episode of Good Mythical Morning, Rhett & Link took on the gauntlet for a Gut Check, tasting every single flavor in rapid fire succession.
They scored each one on a scale of 1 to 100, then whittled down the list to the top four and ranked those. Their palate cleanser? Giant salt licks. So, how did it turn out? Here’s the final four, followed by the full list of what they tried.
The following article contains affiliate links that may generate a small commission to us when you make a purchase through the link. Learn more about how we work with affiliates here.
- Peanut Butter Fudge Core
The peanut butter category treated the guys right. Rhett gave this mix of chocolate and peanut butter ice creams with PB cups an 84. Link gave it an 87. Comparing it to the other finalists, Link decided that “the peanut butteriness is not as pure.”
- Peanut Butter Half Baked
Chocolate and peanut butter ice creams with peanut butter cookie dough and fudge brownies—it’s a PB lover’s dream come true. It got an 89 from Link and an 88 from Rhett, tying for the top scoring ice cream with Peanut Butter World. When it came down to it though, Rhett said, “It’s good but I’m missing the straight-up peanut butter.”
- The Tonight Dough
Link gave an 89 to this ice cream featuring his BFF, Jimmy Fallon. “Sorry, Jimmy, it’s not that good,” Rhett said. He gave it a still respectable 76, which sent it into the final round, where it landed in the number two spot. “Two types of dough?!” Link said. Who could ask for anything more?
- Peanut Butter World
“I can’t believe I’ve never had that,” said Link. he gave the milk chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and chocolate cookie swirls an 87. “That is good!” Rhett exclaimed, and gave it a 90. “The real peanut butter swirl does something for me,” Rhett said when they retasted this finalist. “It’s the best by a long shot.”
Every Ben & Jerry’s Flavor the Guys Tried: Urban Bourban, Chillin the Roast, Cannoli, Everything But The …, Pistachio Pistachio, Karamel Sutra Core, Chubby Hubby, Ice Cream Sammie, Sweet Like Sugar Cookie Dough Core, Phish Food, New York Super Fudge Chunk, Justice Remix’d, Boom Chocolatta! Cookie Core, Vanilla Caramel Fudge, Vanilla, Salted Caramel Almond, Triple Caramel Chunk, Coffee Coffee Buzz Buzz Buzz, Cold Brew Caramel Latte, Minter Wonderland, Cherry Garcia, Salted Caramel Core, Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch, Milk & Cookies, Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake, Gimme S’More, Chocolate Therapy, Mint Chocolate Cookie, Chunky Monkey, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Cookies & Cream Cheesecake Core, Strawberry Cheesecake, Wake & No Bake Cookie Dough Core, Oat of This Swirled, Americone Dream, Chocolate Shake It, S’mores, Glampfire Trail Mix, Pumpkin Cheesecake, Cinnamon Bun, Red White & Blueberry, Peanut Butter Cup, Half Baked Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Brewed to Matter, Brownie Batter Core, Netflix & Chill’d,