Of the fast food desserts, a Frosty from Wendy’s is up there as one of the most iconic and classic options. To us, the only things that come close to it are the McFlurry and Apple Pie from McDonald’s. Regardless, though, with each new iteration of Wendy’s Frosty we see come out as a part of seasonal or promotional menus, they seem to prove how versatile and reinvent-able they truly are.
Videos by Sporked
After all, they are basically just soft-serve ice cream. So the fact that they can shape-shift quite easily into other seasonal treats doesn’t really come as much of a shock to us. But, that doesn’t automatically mean that each and every flavor of the Frosty is going to be perfect. Thus, when we heard this Peppermint Frosty Swirl would be returning to the Wendy’s menu in both chocolate and vanilla versions, we knew we’d have to try them out and report back to our dear readers. Here’s what we thought.
Vanilla Peppermint Frosty Swirl
For as logical of a combination as it may have seemed, the specific flavor of the Vanilla Frosty did not pair well with the peppermint drizzle. For starters, the peppermint itself was quite artificial tasting. But it was also quite gritty with a not-that-pleasant texture beyond that either. It was sticky, gloopy, and gritty. And that, the fact that the flavors really didn’t mesh very well together, and the lack of integration between the two components altogether made this a generally very disappointing treat.
Chocolate Peppermint Frosty Swirl
Well, all of our issues with the swirl itself still held true in this Frosty. But we had different (and less egregious) issues with this treat, too. Because of the overall creamy, mellow flavor of the chocolate Frosty itself, when you got a bite with both the swirl and the Frosty you could only really taste peppermint. The chocolate was totally overwhelmed by a swirl flavor that wasn’t all too impressive on its own. If the best part of these bites were where you could basically barely taste the swirl altogether, then we really just preferred the chocolate Frosty overall. Rather than being an improvement to an iconic, delicious treat, the Peppermint Swirls were a burden. That said, if you’re still looking to try one of these our, far and by we’d recommend the chocolate version as opposed to the vanilla.
Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!