Best Cookies and Cream Ice Cream: The 5 Best You Can Buy

The best cookies and cream ice cream should be creamy and chocolatey, but neither flavor should overpower the other. The cookies and the cream must be perfectly balanced to make a pint of ice cream the best cookies and cream ice cream.

And, in my opinion, the most important factor is that the “cream” part of the cookies and cream ice cream actually tastes like cream and not vanilla. It’s not cookies and vanilla. It’s cookies and cream! After tasting what felt like hundreds of different cookies and cream ice creams, we found five that we think are exceptional. Below are the best cookies and cream ice creams to have in your freezer the next time a craving strikes.

The following article contains affiliate links that may generate a small commission to us when you make a purchase through the link. Learn more about how we work with affiliates here.


Best of the Best

Dreyer’s / Edy’s Cookies ‘N Cream Ice Cream

For some reason, I would never think to buy Dreyer’s ice cream. The carton looks so plain compared to some of the other, flashier brands on the market. This is a great example of how you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, though. Dreyer’s Cookies ‘N Cream ice cream was better than any other cookies and cream ice cream we tried. It’s creamy, there are plenty of cookie chunks, and it’s affordable! What’s not to like? And if you can’t find it in your local grocery store, look for Edy’s. It’s the same brand.

Credit: Paula Kunatee / Vons

Rating:

10/10

Sporks

Best Organic

Alden’s Organic Cookies & Cream Ice Cream

Buying Alden’s ice cream feels like buying ice cream from a farm. It gives off a very small-batch, local vibe. The base is very rich and has that milk flavor I’m looking for in a cookies and cream ice cream. Compared to some of the others we tried, it isn’t too sweet. I know it sounds strange to describe an ice cream as mild, but this one is mild in such a pleasant way. To me, this is the perfect after-dinner ice cream when you want something just a little sweet.

Credit: Paula Kunatee / Instacart

Rating:

9/10

Sporks

Best Mix-Ins

Ben & Jerry’s Topped Dirt Cake Frozen Dessert

This Ben & Jerry’s ice cream consists of  vanilla pudding ice cream with chocolate sandwich cookies, chocolate cookie swirls, a milk chocolate ganache top layer, and chocolate cookie crumbs. This ice cream is the furthest possible thing from subtle and that’s why I love it. This is dessert punching you in the face. It’s super sweet, wildly messy, and unbelievably decadent. You’d probably have to go to the hospital if you ate an entire pint, but there’s no other way I’d rather die.

Credit: Paula Kunatee / Target

Rating:

9/10

Sporks

Best Budget

Great Value Cookies & Cream Ice Cream

If you regularly read our articles, this is no surprise to you. Great Value almost always makes the list. The quality for the price is truly great. This cookies and cream ice cream has huge pieces of chocolate sandwich cookies, and the texture of the base is nice and smooth. If you want a sweet treat but your paycheck hasn’t hit your account yet this month, head to Walmart to buy the best cookies and cream ice cream you can get on a budget.

Credit: Paula Kunatee / Walmart

Rating:

8.5/10

Sporks

Best Splurge

Häagen-Dazs Cookies & Cream Ice Cream

Before I started at Sporked, I wasn’t sure if Häagen-Dazs ice cream was worth the money. Because it’s a little pricier than some other brands, I didn’t buy it and told myself it was overhyped. Now, I must reckon with the fact that I was very wrong. Everything Häagen-Dazs makes is great. This was one of the best cookies and cream ice creams we tried during our taste test. It’s super creamy and just feels expensive. My only complaint is that it needs more mix-ins, but that’s just a personal preference.

Credit: Paula Kunatee / Target

Rating:

8/10

Sporks

Other Products We Tried: Haagen-Dazs, Kroger, Breyers, Breyers Non-Dairy, Turkey Hill, Baskin Robbins, Tillamook, Private Selection, Oreo, Signature Select, Planet Oat Cookies & Creme, Fairlife Cookies & Cream, Van Leeuwen, Blue Bunny, Favorite Day

Find the best cookies and cream ice cream at home and share with us using #SporkedTasteTest for a chance to be featured on our social pages!


About the Author

Jordan Myrick

Jordan is an L.A.-based writer and comedian who believes all food should come with extra sauce. When they're not writing for Sporked, Jordan is at the movies or sharing an order of french fries with their elderly chihuahua.

Thoughts? Questions? Complete disagreement? Leave a comment!

Your thoughts.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • You’re wrong cause it’s Blue Bell. Texas Baby.

    Reply