This 5 Pound Sam’s Club Pie Is Back Just In Time For Fall 

If you’ve been on the hunt for a decadent, dreamy fall dessert that’s oh-so-seasonal, good news. We’ve found it for you — and it’s back in stock at Sam’s Club after going out of stock for a few months.

Videos by Sporked

This dessert is so in-demand that, when it appears annually as it has over the last couple of years, Sam’s Club shoppers immediately flock to their local store to stock up. (And yes, I’m absolutely adding one to my Sam’s must-haves list this week!) It’s a pie, but it’s nothing like your typical home-baked pies. It’s miles better and impressively hefty, clocking in at roughly 5 pounds so no one leaves your dinner table with a still-growling stomach.

It’s So Good, It Keeps Winning Awards (and Fans)

The pie in question is the Member’s Mark Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie, a festive fall treat that appears in Sam’s Club bakeries every fall. If you tried the Member’s Mark Cherry Lattice Pie this summer, this is the newest seasonally-inspired version to hit stores.

This classic dessert features all of the elements you know and love from a homemade apple pie, but it takes them to the next level with extra-delicious touches and a pretty significant size.

In fact, this nearly 5-pound Sam’s Club pie is so tasty that it’s actually earned multiple awards. It’s a repeat winner, grabbing awards at the National Pie Championships in 2024 and 2026. The Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie nabs the championship with its baked apple filling, which is made with sugar and cinnamon for that classic apple pie flavor. The crust, which is buttery and just the right amount of flaky, is also a standout touch.

 And when it comes to the size, trust me: This is a pie that’ll please an entire crowd. The 12-inch pie weighs an impressive 75 ounces, or just over 4.5 pounds, before you add toppings like ice cream or whipped cream. And it costs just under $11.

A bulk buy pie and an affordable price? Now that’s why we keep going back to the Sam’s Club bakery.

You Need to Try the Member’s Mark Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie This Fall

If you have yet to dig into the Member’s Mark Honeycrisp Apple Lattice Pie, now’s your chance to pick one up for fall. And once you try it, odds are you’ll agree with shoppers who’s called it “a very good apple pie,” “better than Grandma’s,” and said that it “compares favorably to the best apple pie in the world” — in fact, you just might want to keep this pie in mind for all of your fall holidays like Thanksgiving. 

And if you’re not ready to invest in a nearly 5-pound pie right now, don’t worry. You can still give it a try by stopping by the Sam’s Club food court, where it’s one of the ingredients in the Member’s Mark Americana Sundae alongside ice cream.