Your favorite Pop-Tart flavor can say a lot about you. Whether you prefer a classic or something chocolatey or fruit-forward, your Pop-Tart choice is personal. Rhett & Link are big breakfast fans and after trying almost every single Pop-Tart on the market, these are the ones they preferred.
On the August 20, 2020, episode of Good Mythical Morning, Rhett & Link did a “Gut Check” and gave impulsive opinions for each flavor of the 32 Pop-Tarts they were hand-fed. Some were underwhelming, some were unexpected, and these three were deemed practically perfect. We’re happy to report that we agree with them!
The following article contains affiliate links that may generate a small commission to us when you make a purchase through the link. Learn more about how we work with affiliates here.
- Frosted S’mores
Rhett & Link both agreed that the S’mores Pop-Tart is a “solid” option. They loved the “beautiful cross-section” and felt the s’mores flavor was strong while not being overpowering. Link stated that “the ratio is even better than an actual s’more.” This one landed itself in the bronze toaster. The only reason it wasn’t higher on the list is that Rhett felt that fruit-flavored Pop-Tarts simply can’t be beaten.
- Frosted Blueberrific Crisps
Unlike regular Pop-Tarts, Crisps are not designed for the toaster. Link was partial to these because “it’s just so easy to bite them.” Rhett & Link preferred the blueberry over the other fruit Crisps because it had a stronger flavor. Unfortunately, these Pop-Tart Crisps appear to be sensationally hard to find IRL. Because they had slightly less of a fruit punch than the winners, these slipped into the silver toaster.
- Wildlicious! Frosted Wild Berry
Rhett & Link loved how much filling was in these Wildlicious! Wild Berry Pop-Tarts. Link also insisted that, since the filling is technically fruit, these belong “squarely in the breakfast zone” and can be eaten first thing in the morning. Rhett & Link gave the coveted golden toaster spot to the Wild Berry Pop-Tarts because they determined that fruit is the best type of Pop-Tart, and these had the best fruit flavor.
Other Pop-Tarts the Guys Tried: Fruit Loops, Raspberry, Simply Frosted Orchard Apple Cinnamon, Strawberry, Simply Frosted Harvest Strawberry, Unfrosted Blueberry, Crispy Apple, Unfrosted Strawberry, Strawberry Milkshake, Blueberry, Cherry, Red White & Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolatey Churro, Chocolate Fudge, Chocolate Cupcake, Pretzel Chocolate, Cinnamon Roll, Confetti Cupcake, Crisps Strawberrylicious, Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Cookies & Cream, Sugar Cookie, Pretzel Cinnamon Sugar, Unfrosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Hot Fudge Sundae, Crisps Appletastic, Mer-Mazing Blue Raspberry.